This response to Paul S. Karleen was originally a paper presented on Nov. 16, 1989, to the Dispensational Study Group in San Diego. pdf here. It was then published with the same title in Grace Theological Journal 10/2 (1989): 147-155. It is used with permission from Brethren Digital Archives. The full issue of the Grace Theological Journal, which contains Karleen’s paper (“Understanding Covenant Theologians: A Study in Presuppositions,” Grace Theological Journal 10/2 : 125-138) and Gerry Breshears’s summary of the subsequent discussion (“Dispensational Study Group Discussion,” Grace Theological Journal 10/2 : 161-164), is available at the Brethren Digital Archives. There is a related response to Robert L. Saucy, which comes from the same meeting.